The first pastor was Rev. Allen Hooper, who served for two years and was called to rest. The second pastor was Rev. Jeff McKesson, who served for three years. During this time, the service was rendered by Rev. York Brock and Rev. Ed Williams. Rev. Willie Benderson was elected as the third pastor. Under his leadership, the church adopted a new name, which is the Christian Chapel Baptist Church.

In 1909, Christian Chapel was destroyed by fire and was rebuilt in 1912 by Dec. Richard Smith. Rev. Benderson remained pastor until the early 1920s. After Rev. Benderson left, several other ministers visited.

The fourth pastor to serve was Rev. William Rowser, who served for a short time.

In 1955, the church elected Rev. C. H. Williams, who served until 1959. After Rev. Williams left, Rev. Thomas served a short time.

Following Rev. Giben, the church elected Rev. L. H. Evans as the next pastor. He served well until his death in 1978. Under Rev. Evans' administration, Brother Barry James and Brother Williams Scott were ordained as deacons.

During the latter part of 1978, Rev. James Brown was elected as the next pastor. During his leadership, the church grew and expanded. The kitchen, bathrooms, and classrooms were added to the building. After serving for four years, Rev. Brown decided to pastor closer to his home in Tuscaloosa. After Rev. Brown's administration, the church was again without a pastor and was visited by Rev. Massey and Rev. T. Evans. It was not until Rev. M. A. Walker visited that the church held an election. Rev. Walker was elected as the new pastor. He served for three years. During this term, two brothers were ordained as deacons: Dec. Willie B. Winters and Dec. James Maxwell. Rev. Walker resigned shortly thereafter.

In July of 1985, Rev. Freddie Moore was elected pastor. Under his leadership, the Sunday School increased by 40 members. A bible class was organized and the Missionary Society became active. Numerous auxiliaries were established. The Deaconess Board was reactivated. Improvements were made in the kitchen. A private bathroom and a private telephone was installed in the Pastor's Study. The Study was then moved to an office in the rear of the church. The Fellowship Hall was furnished; new chairs were given by the members. Also during this administration, the church mortgage was paid in full. A Scholarship Fund was established to help some of the less fortunate members to attend trade school or college.